Four-Year Foresthill Cold Case Leads Investigators to Victim’s Family
FORESTHILL, Calif. — A disturbing discovery in the foothills of Placer County during the 2022 Mosquito Fire has resulted in two arrests after investigators used advanced DNA technology to identify a man whose severed head was found in a trash bag more than four years ago.
The Placer County Sheriff’s Office announced Nov. 18 that the remains belonged to Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., who was 73 years old at the time of his death.
His wife, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, and their daughter, Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, were arrested Nov. 17 following a search warrant served at their former family residence on Lichen Drive in Citrus Heights.
Investigators allege that Mary killed her father at the family home and that she and her mother subsequently conspired to dispose of his remains.
The case has drawn attention across the Sacramento region, particularly in the foothill communities surrounding Foresthill, where the original discovery remained an unsolved mystery for years.
A gruesome discovery in Todd Valley
The investigation began Sept. 28, 2022, when Placer County deputies responded to a report of a severed human head discovered inside a trash bag in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill.
The discovery occurred while the Mosquito Fire was burning in the surrounding foothills, bringing emergency crews and public safety agencies into the region.
Investigators initially faced significant challenges identifying the victim. The condition of the remains prevented an immediate identification, and detectives could not connect the discovery to any missing-person report or known homicide investigation.
An autopsy was conducted, and the victim’s skull was sent to California State University, Chico, where forensic specialists developed a preliminary age and racial profile. They also created an artist’s rendering in an effort to generate leads.
Investigators entered the victim’s DNA into the FBI’s Combined DNA Index System, commonly known as CODIS. However, the database search produced no matches.
Genetic genealogy provides the breakthrough
In January 2024, investigators submitted the victim’s DNA to Othram Labs for forensic genetic genealogy testing.
Unlike conventional DNA database searches, forensic genetic genealogy can help investigators identify potential relatives by examining genetic connections and constructing family trees.
Othram developed a genealogical profile that pointed investigators toward possible distant relatives of the unidentified man.
With assistance from the FBI, Placer County detectives began tracing the family tree. FBI agents helped interview distant relatives and obtain DNA samples for comparison.
Those efforts eventually established the victim’s identity as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr.
The identification changed the direction of the investigation.
Detectives discovered that Fitzmaurice had never been reported missing, despite having died years earlier.
According to the Sheriff’s Office, he had last been known to live in Citrus Heights with his wife and adult daughter.
Investigators trace the case to Citrus Heights
As detectives examined Fitzmaurice’s family circumstances, investigators developed evidence that led them to believe his death occurred at the family’s Citrus Heights residence.
The Sheriff’s Office alleges that Mary Fitzmaurice was responsible for her father’s murder and that she and her mother worked together to dispose of his remains.
During a news conference, Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo described how the women allegedly maintained the appearance that Fitzmaurice was still alive.
“They kept up the facade to family and friends that Paul was still alive,” Woo said.
According to investigators, the women told some of Fitzmaurice’s estranged relatives that he was a recluse who periodically disappeared for days at a time.
The investigation also uncovered allegations that the women continued receiving his Social Security benefits and California Public Employees’ Retirement System pension after his death.
Authorities have not publicly established a motive for the alleged killing.
Mother and daughter arrested
On Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, detectives with the Placer County Sheriff’s Office served a search warrant at the family’s residence on Lichen Drive in Citrus Heights.
Both women were arrested later that day and booked into the South Placer Jail.
Mary Fitzmaurice was booked on a murder charge, while her mother was booked on accessory charges.
The Placer County Sheriff’s Office credited its Crimes Against Persons detectives and Cold Case Investigations Team for the work that ultimately identified the victim and developed the case.
The FBI assisted with the genealogical investigation and provided its Evidence Response Team during the execution of the search warrant.
Additional assistance came from the Citrus Heights Police Department and the Contra Costa County Crime Lab, which provided advanced DNA testing. The Placer County Cold Case Foundation helped fund testing that played a critical role in identifying the victim.
Questions remain unanswered
Despite the arrests, several significant questions remain.
Investigators have not publicly disclosed the motive for the killing, and the remainder of Fitzmaurice’s body has not been located.
Authorities also have not provided a complete account of how the remains were transported from Citrus Heights to the Todd Valley area of Foresthill.
The investigation has raised additional questions about the alleged collection of Social Security and public pension benefits after Fitzmaurice’s death.
The Placer County District Attorney’s Office has been reviewing the evidence and potential charges.
A felony complaint filed Nov. 19 lists Mary Elizabeth Fitzmaurice as a defendant in a murder count alleging that she killed Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice during the period of Sept. 16-28, 2022. The allegations remain subject to proof in court.
As of the latest available court reporting, the women’s arraignment had been continued to Dec. 4, 2026.
For residents of Foresthill and the surrounding foothill communities, the case brings an extraordinary development to a mystery that began with an unidentified victim discovered in their region during one of the area’s most significant wildfire emergencies.
Four years later, investigators have put a name to the victim and traced the case hundreds of miles through family history, forensic science and DNA evidence.
The investigation continues.
Geographic context for El Dorado County readers
Foresthill is located in Placer County, northeast of Auburn, rather than El Dorado County. However, the community’s proximity to the Sierra Nevada foothills and the shared regional wildfire environment make this an important story for residents throughout the greater foothill region.
The discovery occurred during the Mosquito Fire, which burned across portions of Placer and El Dorado counties in September 2022. The case also illustrates how modern forensic technology can reopen investigations that once appeared to have reached a dead end.
Primary source: Placer County Sheriff’s Office — Official Nov. 19 announcement.
Additional reporting and records:








