Placerville Newswire
  • Crime
  • Culture
No Result
View All Result
Get Started
Placerville NewsWire
  • Crime
  • Culture
No Result
View All Result
Placerville NewsWire
No Result
View All Result

Supreme Court Appears Likely to Side Against El Dorado County TIM Fees

The US Supreme Court signaled a narrow victory for property owners challenging permitting fees while leaving the tougher issues for another day

Cris Alarcon by Cris Alarcon
January 9, 2024
in News
450 19
0
Supreme Court Appears Likely to Side Against El Dorado County TIM Fees
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterWhatsappReddit

El Dorado County (January 9, 2024) – The Supreme Court displayed a keen interest in re-evaluating the rights of property owners during a hearing on Tuesday. A California property owner, George Sheetz, seemed to gain traction in his challenge against $23,420 permitting fees incurred while constructing a new house. The court indicated agreement on a narrow aspect that could overturn a California appeals court ruling. Justice Neil Gorsuch suggested a return for arguments on broader questions concerning the county fee’s permissibility. Sheetz’s case challenges El Dorado County’s Traffic Impact Mitigation Fee Program, arguing violations of constitutional tests outlined in Nollan v. California Coastal Commission and Dolan v. City of Tigard. El Dorado defends the fee as distinct from Nollan and Dolan scrutiny. The court’s deliberations signify a broader interest in balancing government regulations with property owner rights, reflecting a trend in the Supreme Court’s attention to property rights and takings cases.

High-stakes Legal Battle Over $23,420 Building Fee Puts California’s Impact Fees in the Crosshairs

In a potentially groundbreaking case with far-reaching consequences, the Supreme Court heard arguments today in a dispute between a 72-year-old retiree, George Sheetz, and El Dorado County over a $23,420 building fee. The case delves into the justifiability of “impact fees” imposed on new construction projects to offset the strain on local infrastructure.

You might also like

Rural Hunger Conference 2025: El Dorado Partners Reinforce Countywide Food Safety Net

Rural Hunger Conference 2025: El Dorado Partners Reinforce Countywide Food Safety Net

October 23, 2025
Mountain lions in El Dorado County peak at dusk and after dark, local monitoring shows

Mountain lions in El Dorado County peak at dusk and after dark, local monitoring shows

October 20, 2025

At the heart of the matter is the extent to which cities and counties must substantiate these fees. In California, where impact fees can substantially increase housing project costs, the outcome could reshape local government budgets and impact housing markets nationwide.

Sheetz, backed by the Pacific Legal Foundation, contends that El Dorado County failed to prove the fee’s correlation with the wear and tear his small project would impose on local roads. His argument challenges a four-decade-old Supreme Court precedent and seeks to establish new standards for justifying such fees.

While Sheetz’s case draws support from building industry groups and property rights advocates, city and county government associations, along with the state and federal governments, rally behind El Dorado County. The court grappled with whether the fee should be treated as government seizure, a simple tax, or an intermediate category.

California’s reliance on impact fees, exacerbated by Proposition 13’s limitations on property taxes, makes this case particularly crucial. The court’s conservative majority, expected to align with Sheetz, may demand heightened scrutiny for justifying fees, potentially affecting widely-used housing and revenue-raising policies.

The case highlights a broader debate on the reasonableness of impact fees, which in 2015 were four times higher in California than in other states. The outcome could impact local financing for infrastructure, and critics argue it may slow down development processes, exacerbating the ongoing housing crisis.

As the Supreme Court grapples with the complexity of the case, its decision may set a precedent, opening a constitutional discussion with implications for various types of fees, including those tied to public art or affordable housing mandates. The outcome remains uncertain, with potential implications for property owners, local governments, and housing affordability in California and beyond.

Source: Sheetz v. County of El Dorado
Cris Alarcon

Cris Alarcon

Former Member: Executive Board of Directors, Treasurer, Boys & Girl Club of El Dorado County Western Slope. - Former Member: Board of Directors, Treasurer, Food Bank of El Dorado County. - Opening Team Dealer at Red Hawk Casino - Retried EDC Elections Department Inspector. - Youngest Charter Member of the Hangtown Kennel Club. - Political Strategist and Campaign Manager.

Related Stories

Rural Hunger Conference 2025: El Dorado Partners Reinforce Countywide Food Safety Net

Rural Hunger Conference 2025: El Dorado Partners Reinforce Countywide Food Safety Net

by Cris Alarcon
October 23, 2025

More than 30 agencies met at the Food Bank of El Dorado County’s Rural Hunger Conference to shore up the...

Mountain lions in El Dorado County peak at dusk and after dark, local monitoring shows

Mountain lions in El Dorado County peak at dusk and after dark, local monitoring shows

by Cris Alarcon
October 20, 2025

New local monitoring shows mountain-lion detections in El Dorado County cluster at dusk and after dark. Cameras capture a 1...

Duane Wallace steps back from South Tahoe Chamber as city leadership faces turmoil over mayor’s resignation

Duane Wallace steps back from South Tahoe Chamber as city leadership faces turmoil over mayor’s resignation

by Cris Alarcon
October 18, 2025

Duane Wallace has stepped away from day-to-day leadership at the South Tahoe Chamber as the city reels from Mayor Tamara...

Tamara Wallace Retains Placerville Attorney Steven C. Bailey in El Dorado County Investigation

Tamara Wallace Retains Placerville Attorney Steven C. Bailey in El Dorado County Investigation

by Cris Alarcon
October 15, 2025

Former South Lake Tahoe Mayor Tamara Wallace announced today she has retained former El Dorado County judge and defense attorney...

Recommended

Placerville Man Arrested for Shooting left another man injured

Mayhem, Mischief & Maybes: El Dorado County Crime Activity Blotter – May 7, 2025

May 8, 2025
EDSO Eagle

EDC Arrests and Activity on May 2 2024

May 3, 2024

Popular Story

  • Feds Charge Two in Alleged Fraud Linked to California’s Homekey Program

    Feds Charge Two in Alleged Fraud Linked to California’s Homekey Program

    689 shares
    Share 276 Tweet 172
  • El Dorado County Sheriff Arrests & Activity Log: Felonies, DUIs, and Domestic Calls — Oct. 18, 2025

    682 shares
    Share 273 Tweet 171
  • El Dorado County Sheriff’s Blotter: Battery Arrest, Domestic Violence, and a Missing Person — Oct. 17, 2025

    680 shares
    Share 272 Tweet 170
  • El Dorado County Arrest Log: Drunks, Thieves, and Probation Breakers Fill the Jail — Oct. 16, 2025

    645 shares
    Share 258 Tweet 161
  • El Dorado County Sheriff Arrest Log: Drunks, Thieves, and a Fugitive on the Run – Oct. 15, 2025

    711 shares
    Share 284 Tweet 178
  • Buy JNews
  • Support Forum
  • Pre-sale Question
  • Contact Us

© 2023 Placerville Newswire Commentary is produced by the Placerville Newswire, a private service focusing on Placerville Local Area issues. All conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s). You may find us in El Dorado County Placerville, CA 95667

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Landing Page
  • Buy JNews
  • Support Forum
  • Pre-sale Question
  • Contact Us

© 2023 Placerville Newswire Commentary is produced by the Placerville Newswire, a private service focusing on Placerville Local Area issues. All conclusions expressed in this publication should be understood to be solely those of the author(s). You may find us in El Dorado County Placerville, CA 95667