EL DORADO COUNTY SHERIFF’S BLOTTER — MARCH 30, 2026
Arranged by Local Area
MOST SERIOUS ARRESTS SPOTLIGHT
David Shawn Pingree — Robbery (Felony), Domestic Violence (Felony), Battery; $107,500 bail
A violent mix of charges tied to a single stop on Emerald Bay Road puts this arrest at the top of the sheet.
Michael Jovan Gutierrez — Attempt to Disarm Officer (Felony), Probation Violation, Drug Possession; $109,000 bail
Allegations of going for an officer’s weapon elevate this from a routine street contact to a high-risk arrest.
Heather Ann Flynn — Grand Theft from Motor Vehicle (Felony); $50,000 bail
A straight felony theft case with a steep bail tied to property taken from a vehicle.
EL DORADO COUNTY SHERIFF’S BLOTTER — MARCH 30, 2026
Arranged by Local Area
SOUTH LAKE TAHOE
Pingree, David Shawn — 1313 Emerald Bay Rd
Gutierrez, Michael Jovan — Lake Tahoe Blvd/Hebert
Brodeur, Brian David — 4087 Sunrise Lane
Buhl, Jacob Dylan — Hwy 89
WEST SLOPE / COUNTY
Flynn, Heather Ann — Bozeman Mt
Nichols, James Allen — Clear Creek Rd/Rivendale
Mitchell, Jonathan Bobby — 5972 Pony Express Trail
ARRESTS
Flynn, Heather Ann
Booking Number: 135973
Booking Date: 3/30/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: EDSOW
Original Arrest Date: 3/30/2026 12:08 AM
Original Arrest Location: Bozeman Mt
Total Bail: $50000.00
Charge(s):
1 487(A) PC Grand theft:money/labor/property – From motor vehicle (F) Felony EDSOW 3/30/2026 12:08 AM Bozeman Mt $50000.00
Pingree, David Shawn
Booking Number: 135974
Booking Date: 3/30/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: SLTPD
Original Arrest Date: 3/30/2026 1:38 AM
Original Arrest Location: 1313 Emerald Bay Rd
Total Bail: $107500.00
Charge(s):
1 273.5(A) PC Inflict corporal injury on spouse/cohabitant/datng relatnshp – Aggravated (F) Felony SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:38 AM 1313 Emerald Bay Rd $50000.00
1 243(E)(1) PC Battery:spouse/ex spouse/date/etc – Simple (M) Misdemeanor SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:38 AM 1313 Emerald Bay Rd $7500.00
1 211 PC Robbery (F) Felony SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:38 AM 1313 Emerald Bay Rd $50000.00
Gutierrez, Michael Jovan
Booking Number: 135978
Booking Date: 3/30/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: SLTPD
Original Arrest Date: 3/30/2026 1:37 PM
Original Arrest Location: Lake Tahoe Blvd/hebert
Total Bail: $109000.00
Charge(s):
1 11377(A) HS Possess controlled substance (M) Misdemeanor SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:37 PM Lake Tahoe Blvd/hebert $1000.00
1 1203.2(A) PC Probation violation:rearrest/revoke (F) Felony SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:37 PM Lake Tahoe Blvd/hebert $0.00
1 148(D) PC Attempt to remove/etc firearm from peace officer/etc – Intimidation (F) Felony SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:37 PM Lake Tahoe Blvd/hebert $100000.00
1 148(A)(1) PC Obstruct/resist/etc public/peace officer/emergency med tech (M) Misdemeanor SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:37 PM Lake Tahoe Blvd/hebert $3000.00
1 242 PC Battery on person – Simple (M) Misdemeanor SLTPD 3/30/2026 1:37 PM Lake Tahoe Blvd/hebert $5000.00
Nichols, James Allen
Booking Number: 135979
Booking Date: 3/30/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: EDSO
Original Arrest Date: 3/30/2026 2:24 PM
Original Arrest Location: Clear Creek Road/ Rivendale
Total Bail: $0.00
Charge(s):
1 459 PC Burglary – Burglary/breaking and entering (F) Felony EDSO 3/30/2026 2:24 PM Clear Creek Road/ Rivendale $0.00
Brodeur, Brian David
Booking Number: 135981
Booking Date: 3/30/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: SLTPD
Original Arrest Date: 3/30/2026 9:31 PM
Original Arrest Location: 4087 Sunrise Lane
Total Bail: $10000.00
Charge(s):
1 1551(A) PC Fugitive from justice:warrant arrest (F) Felony SLTPD 3/30/2026 9:31 PM 4087 Sunrise Lane $10000.00
Buhl, Jacob Dylan
Booking Number: 135982
Booking Date: 3/30/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: TCHP
Original Arrest Date: 3/30/2026 10:15 AM
Original Arrest Location: Hwy 89
Total Bail: $0.00
Charge(s):
1 3056 PC Violation parole:felony (F) Felony TCHP 3/30/2026 10:15 AM Hwy 89 $0.00
Mitchell, Jonathan Bobby
Booking Number: 135983
Booking Date: 3/30/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: EDSO
Original Arrest Date: 3/30/2026 10:24 PM
Original Arrest Location: 5972 Pony Express Trl
Total Bail: $20000.00
Charge(s):
1 11378 HS Possess controlled substance for sale (F) Felony EDSO 3/30/2026 10:24 PM 5972 Pony Express Trl $20000.00
See Related Crime stories: http://inedc.com/26/category/crime/
All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The information here is classified by law as public information.
