A 24-year sentence overturned, but the case did not end
PLACERVILLE, Calif. — A criminal case that resulted in a 24-year state prison sentence took an unexpected turn when California’s Third District Court of Appeal overturned the judgment against Andrew Scott Holtzen on Jan. 10, 2025.
The decision returned the case to El Dorado County Superior Court, raising questions about the status of the original convictions, the validity of the sentence and Holtzen’s subsequent incarceration.
The appellate ruling, People v. Holtzen, Case No. C098250, did not determine whether Holtzen was innocent of the underlying charges. Instead, the court found that the trial judge had improperly denied his constitutional right to represent himself.
The original criminal charges
According to the appellate opinion, Holtzen faced three criminal counts in El Dorado County Superior Court Case No. 22CR1805:
-
Two counts of sodomy by force or fear, under California Penal Code section 286(c)(2)(A).
-
One count of corporal injury to a spouse or cohabitant, under Penal Code section 273.5(a).
The prosecution also alleged a prior strike conviction.
Holtzen initially pleaded not guilty. However, after the court denied his request to represent himself, he subsequently entered no-contest pleas to all three charges and admitted the prior strike allegation.
The court imposed an aggregate sentence of 24 years in state prison.
The appellate opinion does not provide details of the underlying incidents or the evidence presented by prosecutors. The justices specifically excluded those details because they were not relevant to the constitutional question before the court.
Why the appellate court overturned the judgment
The central issue involved the Sixth Amendment right to self-representation.
Eight days before trial, Holtzen made an oral request to represent himself under the legal precedent established in Faretta v. California (1975).
He also submitted a signed petition requesting permission to proceed without an attorney.
The trial judge expressed concerns about Holtzen’s ability to understand legal procedures and represent himself effectively. The judge questioned him about his education, understanding of the charges and familiarity with California Penal Code section 654.
Although the judge acknowledged Holtzen’s right to represent himself, the request was denied.
Holtzen’s defense attorney also encouraged the court to deny the request, citing the sensitive nature of the allegations and the complexity of the case.
The prosecution subsequently conceded that the denial was legally improper.
In its decision, the appellate court explained that a defendant who makes a timely and unequivocal request to represent himself, while knowingly and voluntarily waiving the right to counsel, must generally be permitted to do so.
The justices concluded:
“We agree with the parties that the trial court improperly denied defendant’s motion to represent himself.”
The ruling required reversal of the order denying self-representation and vacating all subsequent orders, including execution of the sentence.
The case was returned to the trial court for further proceedings.
A subsequent custody record in 2025
The appellate reversal did not end the public record surrounding Holtzen’s incarceration.
An El Dorado County arrest record published July 30, 2025, lists Holtzen under booking number 132786.
The record identifies Sierra Conservation as the original arrest location and the El Dorado County Sheriff’s Office as the arresting agency.
The booking lists two entries:
-
CDCR detainer.
-
Court removal order.
His booking status was listed as in custody.
That record establishes a subsequent custody event, but it does not establish the legal basis for continued confinement or whether a new judgment had been entered following the appellate reversal.
It also does not establish where Holtzen is currently housed.
The unanswered questions
As of Nov. 21, 2026, two important questions remain unresolved through the publicly accessible records reviewed for this report.
First: What happened to the criminal charges?
The original no-contest pleas and resulting judgment were vacated. The subsequent court proceedings must establish whether Holtzen entered new pleas, went to trial or reached another disposition.
Second: Where is Holtzen now?
The July 2025 custody record establishes that he was listed in custody following the appellate reversal. However, a historical booking record is not proof of his present correctional placement.
The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation maintains an online incarcerated-person locator, but a current placement could not be independently confirmed for this report.
El Dorado County Superior Court provides access to criminal case records through its clerk’s office. Its published records-request procedure allows members of the public to request a case file using Local Form M-5.
The case number is 22CR1805.
The distinction residents should understand
The reversal of Holtzen’s original judgment was a significant legal development, but it should not be confused with an acquittal.
The Court of Appeal did not determine that the underlying charges were false or that Holtzen was factually innocent. It determined that a constitutional error occurred before the original judgment was entered.
That distinction matters when reporting the case and evaluating any subsequent conviction or sentence.
Until the post-remand court records are obtained, the final disposition of Holtzen’s criminal case and his current custody status remain open questions.
Sources and public records
1. People v. Holtzen — California Third District Court of Appeal, Jan. 10, 2025. Appellate decision, Case No. C098250.
2. Placerville NewsWire — July 30, 2025 custody record. Booking No. 132786.
3. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation — CIRIS. Official incarcerated-person search.
4. El Dorado County Superior Court — Record Search Requests. Procedures for obtaining the criminal case file.







