Arrest Made in 2024 Placerville Homicide After Lengthy Investigation
PLACERVILLE, Calif. — April 24, 2026 — Detectives with the El Dorado County Sheriff’s Office have arrested a Sacramento man in connection with the October 2024 killing of Tyson Fiddler, marking a significant development in a case that has gripped the local community for more than a year.
Joshua Joseph Lighthall, 47, was taken into custody April 23 in Shingle Springs and booked into the El Dorado County Jail on a no-bail warrant for murder under California Penal Code 187(a). Authorities confirmed the arrest is the result of what they described as a “lengthy and detailed” 18-month investigation.
Fiddler, whose disappearance sparked widespread concern across Placerville and surrounding areas, was last seen around 1:50 a.m. on Oct. 5, 2024, at PJ’s Roadhouse. He was reported missing shortly thereafter. His body was discovered five days later in a remote area of El Dorado County, though investigators have not publicly disclosed the exact cause of death.
“This arrest reflects the tireless commitment of our detectives and the patience of the community as we worked to build a strong case,”
the sheriff’s office said in a statement.
“We remain dedicated to seeking justice for Tyson and his family.”
According to officials, Lighthall is currently being held without bail at the El Dorado County Jail in Placerville. Court records indicate he faces a homicide charge with an enhancement for the use of a weapon. As of Friday, an arraignment date in El Dorado County Superior Court had not yet been scheduled.
Investigators have released limited details regarding Lighthall’s alleged role in the killing, noting the case remains active. Authorities have not confirmed whether additional suspects may be involved.
Public records indicate Lighthall has worked in various trades, including painting and carpentry, in the Sacramento and Pollock Pines areas. Social media activity suggests he has participated in local disc golf events, though officials have not connected those details to the case.
The arrest has prompted a wave of reaction across the region, where frustration had grown in recent months over the lack of visible progress. Community members expressed both relief and renewed calls for accountability as the case moves into the court system.
While the arrest marks a critical milestone, law enforcement officials emphasized that the investigation is ongoing and urged anyone with additional information to come forward.
ARREST RECORD:
Lighthall, Joshua Joseph
Booking Number: 136262
Booking Date: 4/23/2026 12:00 AM
Status: In Custody
Original Arresting Agency: EDSO
Original Arrest Date: 4/23/2026 5:16 PM
Original Arrest Location: Double Grove St
Total Bail: $0.00
Charge(s): 1 187(A) PC Murder (F) Felony
